NATe: A Tax-Free Alternative to Cloud NAT Gateways

by | 18 Mar 2021

Whether you need to connect multiple cloud instances, communicate with the public internet from private resources, or directly connect to instances in local data centers, chances are you will be using Network Address Translation (NAT) to make that connection. All major cloud providers provide some product or service to provide NAT functionality, and some platforms even provide separate public and private variants. Because cloud instances running in private subnets are unable to access resources like time servers, webpages, or OS repositories without NAT functionality, most users find themselves relying on their cloud platform’s NAT offerings. By simply following their cloud providers’ recommended best practices, users are overpaying for an overcomplicated and inflexible service that a home cable modem does for free.  So why pay so much for such a simple network function?

If You’re Using Cloud Platform NAT Gateway(s), You’re Overspending on Cloud Deployments.

Overspending of any kind in the wake of the economic disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic can be deadly for any business. Yes, some have fared better than others during this challenging time but all organizations have revisited projections and budgets in the face of uncertainty. According to Gartner, the pressure is on for budget holders to optimize costs.

Pre COVID-19
54%
of enterprises planned IT budget increases
Post COVID-19
84%
of enterprises expect IT budget decreases

Where to Start?

Look to the sky! Your cloud bill is likely full of opportunities for savings, especially if your application relies on NAT functionality. Using AWS NAT Gateway pricing as an example, let’s start with the comparative base subscription costs:

 AWS NAT GatewayVNS3 NATe
Subscription$0.045 / hour$0.01 / hour*
Data Processing (TAX)$0.045 / GB$0.00 / GB
* Price includes runtime fees (on-demand t3.nano $.0052 / hr) + NATe subscription ($0.005 / hr)

As you can see from this example, the standalone subscription cost of an AWS NAT gateway is more than the cost of a single t3.medium instance. The already low VNS3 NATe subscription cost will provide you even more savings when you consider the fact that you don’t have to create as many individual NAT gateways, each of which would be  accompanied by an additional AWS NAT Gateway subscription. The cost differential here makes NATe an obvious choice at any deployment scale and we even offer a free NATe license for smaller deployments.

VNS3 NATe is also incredibly scalable because we don’t increase our data processing rates as your bandwidth needs scale.  Below is a pricing table that shows the total cost of running a single NAT Gateway vs a VNS3 NATe instance as the traffic throughput increases in a given month:

GB / MonthAWS NAT GatewayVNS3 NATe
1$32.45$7.20
10$32.85$7.20
100$36.90$7.20
1,000$77.40$7.20
5,000$257.40$7.20
10,000$482.40$7.20
50,000$2,282.40$7.20
100,000$4,532.40$7.20

We also have customers who maintain 100s or 1000s of VPCs with NAT requirements of 1-100 GB per month.  Those enterprise cloud customer at scale have typically seen costs drop to 1/5 of what they would pay for AWS NAT Gateways.  To illustrate this savings, take the example from one of our customers has 1800 VPCs each with a NAT Gateway.  The total data processed through these NAT Gateways is low and averages 10GB / month with much more potential savings for deployments that pass more traffic out the NAT device.

AWS NAT GatewayVNS3 NATe
Monthly Runtime$58,320Monthly Runtime$12,960
Data Processing (TAX)$810Data Processing (TAX)$0
TOTAL PER MONTH$59,130TOTAL PER MONTH$12,960
* Price includes runtime fees (on-demand t3.nano $0.0052 / hr) + NATe subscription ($0.005 / hr)

Total NATe saving per month in this case is $46K and $554K per annum.

Of course, costs savings are not limited to just NAT Gateway spend.  Other opportunities for savings include right sizing instances (latest generation instance families are always less expensive), decommissioning unused services/resources (I’m looking at you load balancers), and reviewing storage strategies (such as EBS).

What is a NAT Gateway?

A NAT Gateway is a network service that performs a simple network function: Network Address Translation for cloud-based servers running in a private network (private VPC subnet). Here is the AWS documentation detailing the NAT Gateway functionality. NAT Gateways perform a specific type of NAT called IP Masquerading, where devices in a private IP network use a single public IP associated with the gateway for communication with the public Internet.

This is the same function that your home modem performs for free. You’re likely leveraging this NAT functionality as you read this post. Basically the NAT functionality on a NAT Gateway or your home modem allow devices on a private network (computers, phones, TVs, refrigerators, toothbrushes, etc. in the case of your home network) to access the Internet and receive responses but not allow devices on the public Internet to initiate connection into your private network. All traffic sent from the private network to the public Internet uses the modem’s public IP address.

NATe to the Rescue!

In response to direct requests by our customers, we created a low-cost, instance-based alternative to NAT Gateways – VNS3 NATe.

Available on AWS PM and Azure MP today:

* No subscription premium but total throughput limited to 50mbps

What is a NATe?

NATe instances are drop-in replacements from Cohesive Networks for NAT Gateways. Simply launch in a VPC/VNET subnet with an Internet Gateway associated, Stop Src/Dst checking (enable IP forwarding), and update the Route Tables associated with the private Subnets to point 0.0.0.0/0 destinations at the NATe instance-id.

Cohesive-Networks_NATe-Network-Diagram_20210318

NATe provides all the functionality of a NAT Gateway plus enterprise grade security and controls at a fraction of the cost. Some of the functional highlights of NATe include:

  • High Performance – run on the smallest instance sizes to maximize value or larger instance for greater total throughput
  • Secure – access to a firewall to allow additional and orthogonal policy enforcement for traffic flows
  • Control – access logs, network tools like tcpdump, status information
  • Customize – leverage the Cohesive Networks Plugin system to add L4-L7 network services to the NATe instance like NIDs, WAF, Proxy, LB, etc.
  • Automate – fully automate the deployment of VNS3 NATe instances as part of your existing deployment framework leveraging the RESTful API to reduce implementation costs.
  • Failover – NATe can be configured in a number of HA architectures to provide the same level of insurance needed for critical infrastructure via instance auto recovery, auto scale groups, and Cohesive Networks’ own Peering and HA Container functionality
  • Upgrade – NATe is fully upgradeable to fully licensed VNS3 controllers deployed as a single application security controller or part of secure network edge mesh

Still Not Convinced?

Cohesive’s NATe offers a dramatically more cost-efficient solution to often critical NAT requirements in cloud deployments of all shapes and sizes. NATe is more flexible, more scalable, and easier to manage than first-party cloud NAT gateways that are charging you a premium for the functionality of a standard consumer modem. If you don’t believe us, we launched a free version of our NATe offering in both the AWS and Azure marketplaces so you can launch and configure them and see for yourself!

Have questions about set-up or pricing? Please to contact us.